Time and Reconciliation: the Christmas Truce


The biologist Robert Sapolsky had a recent essay in The Wall Street Journal on the Christmas Truce of WWI, where he discusses how cooperation might develop under difficult circumstances. I wrote a blogpost on the same topic here a few years ago (in fact, it is still the most viewed thing on this site), and I think we cover much of the same ground. Sapolsky’s essay is better, which I’m fine with; it’s Robert Sapolsky after all.

At the end of the essay, he presents a thought experiment about trying to fast-forward mentally through the passage of time and seeing the present through the eyes of our older, wiser selves. 

“The philosopher Daniel Dennett has pondered a revealing scenario: Someone is undergoing surgery without anesthesia but with absolute knowledge that afterward, she would receive a drug that would erase all memories of the event. Would the pain be less agonizing if she knew that it would be forgotten? Would the same happen to hatred, if you knew that with time, the similarities would become more important than the differences?

A hundred years ago, in a place that was hell on earth, those with the most reasons to hate one another didn’t need even the passage of time to see the similarities. And they were able, however briefly, to cooperate—and to establish some small measure of peace.”

I think the lesson is valuable, since it provides one more method to keep our baser impulses in check. Utilizing the lens of the future — even if we can never truly know what the future is until we get there — could help us gain a little more distance from our immediate circumstances. The hope is that such reflection might provide perspective as to whether hatred and conflict are worth it in the long run. 

The optimist in me likes to think that in the future, people will have figured these things out (what’s the alternative?). If so, then those of us alive today will appear myopic and foolish. 

One thought on “Time and Reconciliation: the Christmas Truce

  1. There is such a drug. 9 years back I had an accident in Vietnam and ended up medivac to a good hospital in Bangkok. Part of the explorations involved a colonoscopy. I had several before that one and always found them uncomfortable, stressful and painful. My request for an anesthetic was turned down with the explanation that my cooperation was needed to move on command, but I was given an injection to ‘relax’ me. I was taken down to the op theatre and waited on the trolley for what seemed a long time to go in. I was so cold I asked a nurse for a blanket and she told me I would be going back to the room in a minute. I then asked if the colonoscopy had been delayed or cancelled and when told I had just had it, I didn’t believe it. I remembered nothing at all. And yes, it’s really much better that way.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s